|
Reading: The Most Important Science Process Skill
Dr. Stan Metzenberg, CSU Northridge
Special to The Antenna
It has become fashionable in science education to mold K-12 students around an idee fixe
[obsession] of a modern scientist; formulating hypotheses, observing measuring, and discovering
through hands-on investigations. What has been left unsaid is that real scientists don't actually spend
very much of their day "observing" and "measuring." They read! Reading for understanding of
content is the core process skill of science, and there is no substitute for practice at an early age.
Consider the changing emphasis that California has placed on reading skills in the past 20 years. In
the 1978 California Science Framework, the issue of reading in science instruction was discussed in
depth in an appendix, and the promotion of specific science vocabulary was a key point. In the 1990
California Science Framework, which mercifully is being rewritten this year, the importance of science
vocabulary was discounted and analyses of the type included in the 1978 framework were
denounced. Many of the popular hands-on kits in current use provide no reading materials for
students at all, and this is the fulfillment of the constructivists' dream. For everyone else it is a
nightmare.
A student who has not developed the skill of learning through reading has no professional future in
science. Without a foundation in scientific vocabulary and with minimal knowledge of scientific fact,
their words bear an accent of ignorance that is impossible to conceal and nearly impossible to
remediate. While young people should be encouraged to enter science, they must also be given the
education that will permit them to succeed.
Hands-on investigative activities ought to be sprinkled into a science program like a "spice"; they
cannot substitute for a "main dish". The best "hands-on" program would be one in which students can
get their "hands on" an informative textbook!
Stan Metzenberg (stanmetzenberg@csun.edu) was a consultant for the Academics Standards
Commission, and is an Assistant Professor of Biology at California, State University
Northridge. The California Content Standards are available at: http:.//www.k12standards.org.
|