The National Student Research Center
E-Journal of Student Research: Multi-Disciplinary
Volume 3, Number 1, October, 1994


The National Student Research Center is dedicated to promoting student research and the use of the scientific method in all subject areas across the curriculum especially science and math. The E-Journal of Student Research is published quarterly.

For more information contact:

John I. Swang, Ph.D.
Founder/Director
National Student Research Center
2024 Livingston Street
Mandeville, Louisiana 70448
U.S.A.
E-Mail: nsrcmms@communique.net
http://youth.net/nsrc/nsrc.html


                       TABLE OF CONTENTS

Science Section:

1.  Who Can Hold Their Breath The Longest?
2.  Which Crane Will Lift More?
3.  The Effect Of Length On The Musical Pitch Of Organ Pipes 
and Calliope Whistles

Social Studies Section:

1.  Student Knowledge of Land Pollution
2.  What Do Students Think About Gun Control?

Consumerism Section:

1.  The Best Overall Football Magazine
2.  Comparing Grocery Store Prices




SCIENCE SECTION


TITLE:  Holding Your Breath

STUDENT RESEARCHER:  Mr. Carbone's Math Class
SCHOOL:  North Stratfield
         Fairfield, Connecticut
GRADE:  4
TEACHER:  Mr. V. Carbone, M.Ed.



I. STATEMENT OF PURPOSE AND HYPOTHESIS:

We want to find out who can hold their breath the longest.  We 
want to test a sixth, fourth, and third grade class of 
students.  Our hypothesis states that the sixth graders will be 
able to hold their breath the longest.  

II. METHODOLOGY:

We tested third and fourth grade students in Connecticut and 
sixth grade students in Louisiana.  We had each class keep time 
as to how long each student could hold their breath.  All 
students completed two tests.  In the first test, everyone took 
a deep breath and held it.  For the second test, everyone 
exhaled and then held their breath.  

III. ANALYSIS OF DATA:

            Average Time Breath Held   Average Time Breath Held
                      (Inhaled)                 (Exhaled)

Sixth Grade          43.0 Seconds              23.3 Seconds
Fourth Grade         55.8 Seconds              33.5 Seconds
Third Grade          32.3 Seconds              27.3 Seconds


IV. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION:

The fourth graders held their breath the longest in both tests.  
We rejected our hypothesis.  We thought the sixth graders would 
be able to hold their breath the longest because they are 
bigger than the third and fourth grader.  We are not really 
sure why the fourth graders won.  We do know that we had 
trouble with some of the third graders we tested.  Some were 
fooling around.  

V. APPLICATION:

Holding one's breath the longest does not seem to matter on 
size or height.  




TITLE:  Which Crane Will Lift More?

STUDENT RESEARCHER:  Chris Pacilio
SCHOOL:  Dawson Elementary
            Holden, MA
GRADE:  5
TEACHER:  Wayne A. Boisselle


I. STATEMENT OF PURPOSE AND HYPOTHESIS: 
        
I want to find out how much Lego machines can lift.  My 
hypothesis states that the crane with more gears will lift more 
than the crane with fewer gears.

II.  METHODOLOGY:  

First, I wrote my statement of purpose.  Next, I wrote my 
literature review.  Then I wrote my hypothesis.   The next 
thing I did was build my cranes and perform my experiment.  I 
built two types of cranes using Lego Dacta Technique II cards 
and the LogoWriter Robotics program.  The first one I built had 
four gears (two large and two small) set up small to large, 
small to large.  The other crane I built had six gears set up 
the same way as the first crane, except I added another small 
and large gear.  Each crane was attached to a separate base.  I 
then set up each crane with string and cup to hold weight.  I 
started off with 50 grams in the first cup and added 50 grams 
after each trial.  I marked my data on my collection chart.   
Then I analyzed my data and accepted or rejected my hypothesis.  
Finally, I drew my conclusions and applied my data to the real 
world outside of the classroom.

III.  ANALYSIS OF DATA:

Crane 1 with six gears lifted 1,700 g. on both trials and crane 
2 with four gears lifted 250 g. on both trials.  

IV.  SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION:

My data shows that crane 1 lifted more than crane 2 both times.  
Therefore, I accept my hypothesis which stated that the crane 
with more gears will lift more than the crane with fewer gears.

V.  APPLICATION: 

My report will help people in the work world make stronger 
cranes.




TITLE:  The Effects of Length on the Musical Pitch of Organ 
Pipes and Calliope Whistles

STUDENT RESEARCHER:  Don P. Elbers
SCHOOL:  Mandeville Middle School
         Mandeville, Louisiana
GRADE:  6
TEACHER:  Mrs. M. Smith


I.  STATEMENT OF PURPOSE AND HYPOTHESIS:

What is the effect of the length of an organ pipe or calliope 
whistle on the frequency of the sound produced?  My hypothesis 
states that I think that decreasing the length of an organ pipe 
or calliope whistle will result in tones of higher frequencies.  
Lengthening the pipe or whistle will result in the production 
of lower frequency tones.

II.  METHODOLOGY:

A centrifugal blower was used to supply air to different types 
and sizes of organ pipes and calliope whistles.  The length of 
a whistle or pipe, measured with a tape, was varied.  The 
musical pitch, measured with a piano tuner and frequency, 
monitored with a frequency meter, were recorded as the length 
of each device was varied.

III.  ANALYSIS OF DATA:

For each pipe or whistle it is shown by the data collected that 
an increase in length represents a lowering of pitch and 
frequency.  A decrease in length causes the pitch and frequency 
to increase.

IV.  SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION:

The rate of vibration of the air within the pipe or whistle 
increases as the length decreases.  It appears that sound waves 
bounce back and forth within the pipe or whistle, at a higher 
rate, over short distances and a lower rate over long 
distances.

V.  APPLICATION:

If you applied this information to real life you would know how 
to tune calliope whistles such as those on the calliope on the 
Mississippi Queen Riverboat and organ pipes such as those on 
the organ on the City Park Carousel.	



SOCIAL STUDIES SECTION



TITLE:  What Do Students Think About Gun Control?

STUDENT RESEARCHER:  Austin Feldbaum
SCHOOL:  Mandeville Middle School
         Mandeville, Louisiana
GRADE:  6
TEACHER:  John I. Swang, Ph.D.


I.  STATEMENT OF PURPOSE AND HYPOTHESIS:

I wanted to know more about what students think of gun control.  
My hypothesis states that students will be for stricter gun 
control laws.

II.  METHODOLOGY:

First, I wrote my statement of purpose.  Then I did my review 
of literature and developed my hypothesis.  Next, I developed 
my questionnaire, drew a random sample of twelve sixth grade 
students at M.M.S. and administered my survey to them.  Then I 
scored my questionnaires, recorded my data on a data collection 
sheet and analyzed my data with simple charts and graphs.  Then 
I wrote my summary and conclusion.  Next, I applied what I 
found to the real world.  Finally, I wrote an abstract of my 
research and published it in a journal of student research. 

III.  ANALYSIS OF DATA:

I sent out twelve gun control surveys and received eleven back.  
A majority of seven students thought that citizens should be 
allowed to own guns in their homes.  A majority of seven agreed 
with Congress' decision to ban assault rifles and thought that 
there should be a seven day wait before the sale of a handgun.  
A majority of eight students thought that Congress should ban 
rifle clips with over five bullets.  Three of the students 
surveyed thought that Congress should pass gun control laws, 
five thought that each state should pass laws, two said each 
county or parish, and one answered none of the "above".  A 
majority of eight students surveyed thought that gun control is 
our biggest problem in the United States.  A majority of six 
students said that we should not ban all firearms.  Ten 
students said that there should be mandatory jail sentences for 
all crimes committed with a gun.  Seven students thought that 
there should be longer jail sentences for second time gun 
offenders.  Six students did not own a hand gun and only two 
did.  In order to control gun related problems in the United 
States, two students thought that there should be longer jail 
sentences for all crimes committed with a gun, one thought that 
there should be death sentences for all murders using a gun, 
three thought that there should be criminal checks before the 
sale of a gun, and one said that gun buyers should be at least 
twenty-one years of age.  

IV.  SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION:

The majority of the students surveyed thought that there should 
be stricter gun control laws.  Therefore, I accept my 
hypothesis which stated that the majority of the students would 
be for stricter gun control.

V.  APPLICATION:

I could send what I found to the U.S. Congress and state 
governments to tell legislators there what sixth grade students 
at M.M.S. think about gun control.  It could be of help to them 
as they debate this problem and try to solve it.



TITLE:  Student Knowledge of Land Pollution

STUDENT RESEARCHER:  Courtney Lowe
SCHOOL:  Mandeville Middle School
         Mandeville, Louisiana
GRADE:  6
TEACHER:  John I. Swang, Ph.D.


I.  STATEMENT OF PURPOSE AND HYPOTHESIS:

I want to find out how much students know about land pollution.  
My hypothesis states that the students will know a moderate 
amount about land pollution.

II.  METHODOLOGY:

First I wrote my statement of purpose, review of literature, 
and hypothesis.  Next, I wrote my methodology, developed my 
questionnaire, and drew a random sample of twelve sixth grade 
students at MMS.  Then I administered my questionnaire to the 
students at MMS.  When the questionnaires were returned I 
scored them and recorded my data on a data collection sheet.  
Then I conducted my analysis of data with charts and graphs.  
Next, I accepted or rejected my hypothesis, wrote my summary 
and conclusion, and applied my findings to the world.

III.  ANALYSIS OF DATA:

I sent out twelve questionnaires and got them all back.  A 
majority of 7 students said that pollution was the world's 
number 1 problem.  A majority of 10 said that you can't ever 
permanently get rid of pollution.  A majority of 7 knew that 
the USA has 1,207 hazardous waste sites.  A majority of 10 said 
that there was something they could do about pollution.  A 
majority of 9 students agree that the USA has an environmental 
problem.  A majority of 9 students did not know that air 
pollution decreased between 1978 and 1985 due to the Clean Air 
Act passed by Congress.  Half of the students knew that along 
an average one mile stretch of a US highway you would find 
1,457 pieces of litter.  A majority of 7 students knew that an 
average American throws away 3.5 lbs of trash each day.  All 
twelve students said that they recycled their trash and garbage 
at home.

IV.  SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION:

Out of a possible 60 answers to the factual questions, the 
students answered 33 or 56% of the questions correctly and 26 
or 44%  of the questions incorrectly.  I therefore accept my 
hypothesis which states that the majority of the sixth grade 
students will get a moderate amount of the questions correct.

V.  APPLICATION:

I can apply my findings to the world by telling people to think 
before they throw something away or throw something on the 
ground.  In order to reduce pollution,  students must learn to 
recycle, reuse, and conserve energy and natural resources.


CONSUMERISM SECTION



TITLE:  The Best Overall Football Magazine

STUDENT RESEARCHER:  Jeff Carollo
SCHOOL:  Mandeville Middle School
         Mandeville, Louisiana
GRADE:  6
TEACHER:  John I. Swang, Ph.D.


I.  STATEMENT OF PURPOSE AND HYPOTHESIS:

I wanted to find the best overall value for a football 
magazine. I will evaluate price, number of pages, quality of 
pictures and articles, and the number of advertisements.  My 
hypothesis states that "Ultimate Sports Football" will have the 
best overall value.                             

II.  METHODOLOGY:

First, I stated my purpose, reviewed the literature, wrote my 
bibliography, and developed my hypothesis.  Next, I made a data 
collection form and took it to the local magazine store where I 
evaluated five football magazines. I did this by rating 
articles and pictures on a one-low to ten-high scale.  I also 
did this by counting pages and the number of advertisements.  
Then I copied the cover price for each magazine.  I then 
analyzed my data by constructing graphs, charts, and using 
simple statistics.  Next, I summarized my findings and wrote my 
conclusions.  Then I applied my findings to the world.  
Finally, I published my research.     

III.  ANALYSIS OF DATA:

"Pro Football" had one ad per 28 pages, ranking second in that 
category.  It cost four cents per page, ranking fifth in that 
category.  It ranked 10 on a 1 (low) to 10 (high) scale for the 
quality of articles, tying for first in this category.  It 
ranked fourth overall out of the five magazines.

"Peterson's Football" had one ad per seven pages, giving it 
fourth ranking in this category.  It cost only two cents per 
page, tying it for first in this category.  In quality of 
articles, it ranked a ten tying it for first again.  In quality 
of pictures, it ranked ten giving it first place.  It ranked 
first of the five magazines, overall.

"Ultimate Sports Football" had one ad per 36 pages ranking it 
first in this category.  It cost only 3 cents per page, tying 
it for third place.  In quality of articles it, too, ranked a 
ten tying it for first.  The quality of its pictures scored a 
6, ranking it third in this division.  It tied for second, 
overall.

"Sport" had an ad every other page in the magazine, ranking it 
fifth place in this division.  It cost three cents per page, 
tying it for third.  In quality of articles, it scored an 8 
ranking it in fifth place.  In quality of pictures, it scored a 
9 giving it a second place ranking.  It ranked fifth, overall.

"Pro Football Review" had one ad per 25 pages, ranking it third 
in this category.  It cost two cents per page tying it for 
first in this category.  In quality of articles, it ranked a 10 
for a four way tie for first.  In quality of pictures, it 
scored a 6 tying it for third.  Overall ranking of this 
magazine was second place.         

IV.  SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION:

"Peterson's Football" had the best overall value.  Therefore, I 
reject my hypothesis which stated that "Ultimate Sports 
Football" would have the best overall value.   

V.  APPLICATION:

I now know that "Peterson's Football" is the best overall 
football magazine and will use this knowledge while in a 
magazine store.  I can share this information with my father 
who likes reading football magazines. 



TITLE:  Comparing Grocery Store Prices

STUDENT RESEARCHER:  Michael Phillips
SCHOOL:  Mandeville Middle School
         Mandeville, Louisiana
GRADE:  6
TEACHER:  John I. Swang, Ph.D.



I.  STATEMENT OF PURPOSE AND HYPOTHESIS:

I want to find out which local grocery store has the lowest 
prices on the ingredients in Jell-O Mud Cups.  My hypothesis 
states that Winn-Dixie will have the lowest prices on the 
ingredients in Jell-O Mud Cups.

II.  METHODOLOGY:

First, I wrote my statement of purpose, reviewed the literature 
on consumerism, and developed my hypothesis. Then I wrote my 
methodology.  Next, I made my list of materials and made my 
data collection form.  Then I went to A&P, Delchamps, Winn-
Dixie, and Piggly Wiggly and found out the prices of the 
ingredients in Jell-O Mud Cups.  I then wrote my analysis of 
data and either accepted or rejected my hypothesis.  Next, I 
wrote my summary and conclusion and applied my findings to the 
world outside of my classroom.

III.  ANALYSIS OF DATA:

The price of a 16 oz. package of Oreo Cookies at Delchamps was 
$2.99, at A&P it was $2.85, at Winn-Dixie it was $2.58, and at 
Piggly Wiggly it was $2.99.  The price of a quart of Borden 
Skim Milk was $1.09 at Delchamps, $.99 at A&P, $.99 at Winn-
Dixie, and $.99 at Piggly Wiggly.  At Delchamps, the price of a 
3.9 oz. package of Jell-O brand Chocolate Flavored Instant 
Pudding Mix was $.73.  At A&P it was also $.73, at Winn-Dixie 
it was $.61, and at Piggly Wiggly it was $.99.  The price of 
one 8 oz. tub of Cool Whip Lite at Delchamps was $1.26.  At A&P 
it was $1.39, at Winn-Dixie it was $1.33, and at Piggly Wiggly 
it was $1.42.  A package of 16 oz. plastic cups at Delchamps 
was $.90, at A&P t was $1.29, at Winn-Dixie it was $.88, and 
at Piggly Wiggly it was $1.42.  The price of a package of 
Brach's Gummy Worms was $1.35 at Delchamps, $1.39 at A&P, $1.42 
at Winn-Dixie, and $1.29 at Piggly Wiggly.
	
The total cost of all the ingredients in Jell-O mud cups 
including the gas to drive to the grocery stores at Winn-Dixie 
was $8.26, at Delchamps it was $8.51, at A&P it was $8.80, and 
at Piggly Wiggly it was $9.34.

IV.  SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION:

In my research, I found out that Winn-Dixie has the lowest 
prices on the ingredients in Jell-O mud cups.  Therefore, I 
accept my hypothesis which stated that Winn-Dixie would have 
the lowest prices on the ingredients in Jell-O Mud Cups.

V.  APPLICATION:

Next time I make Jell-O mud cups I will go to Winn-Dixie to buy 
the ingredients needed.

© 1994 John I. Swang, Ph.D.